Epistemic theory of vagueness
WebDec 14, 2000 · The Epistemic Theory of Vagueness. Timothy Endicott. Published 14 December 2000. Philosophy. So far we have looked at theories on which vagueness is a … WebThis essay defends an epistemicist response to the phenomenon of vagueness concerning moral terms. I outline a traditional model of -- and then two novel approaches to -- epistemicism about moral predicates, and I demonstrate how the foregoing are able to provide robust explanations of the source of moral, as epistemic, indeterminacy.
Epistemic theory of vagueness
Did you know?
WebThat highly controversial claim is central to the epistemic theory of vagueness, which holds that borderline cases are distinguished by a special kind of obstacle to knowing the truth-value of the statement. But this paper is not a defence of the epistemic theory. WebAfter classifying sources of vagueness for ‘know,’ I spend the second section examining theories of vagueness. With the exception of the theory that vague predicates are incoherent, which I try to refute, we need not take a stand on a particular theory to show that the vagueness of knowledge has substantive epistemological implications.
WebAbstract. Bonini et al. [2] present psychological data that they take to support an ‘epistemic’ account of how vague predicates are used in natural language. We argue that their data … WebFor, as I’ve already said, the epistemic theory entails that one is ignorant of the truth-value of what is said by a vague utterance in a borderline case, and there can be no such ignorance unless the propositions expressed …
WebJan 17, 1997 · In effect, the counter-intuitive aspects of the epistemic theory are avoided only at a cost to other intuitions. ... -schema is said to lead to absurdity (Williamson (1994), ch. 7). This charge applies more generally to any non-bivalent theory of vagueness coupled with the T-schema. If validated, ... Web3.2 The Epistemic Theory. Most theorists of vagueness conceive of vagueness as a semantic phenomenon, as somehow rooted in the meanings of words like ‘tall’ and ‘old’. As we shall see, semantic theories typically introduce special nonclassical logics and/or semantics in order to resolve the paradox (and accommodate the phenomenon of ...
WebJan 1, 2024 · Taking vagueness to be an epistemic phenomenon precludes the sense of agency needed for moral responsibility; taking it to be semantic does not. Thus I advance two arguments for semantic approaches to vagueness, as against epistemic approaches: one descriptive and one normative. Type Articles Information
WebEpistemicism, paradox, and conditional obligation Ivan Hu Philosophical Studies 172 (8):2123-2139 ( 2015 ) Copy BIBTEX Abstract Stewart Shapiro has objected to the epistemicist theory of vagueness on grounds that it gives counterintuitive predictions about cases involving conditional obligation. hiring travel agenciesWebAug 11, 2009 · Sider addresses roughly three types of criteria God might use to determine admittance into Heaven: (1) works, (2) faith, and (3) grace. He argues that each notion admits of borderline cases and thus is subject to the type of vagueness objection above. First, it is clear that any viable works criterion will have borderline cases. homes in gulf shores alabamaWebSep 28, 2000 · Her discussion ranges widely and comprehensively over the main theories of vagueness and their supporting arguments, and she offers a powerful and original … homes in guyana for saleWebJul 10, 2024 · I was reading The Outer Limits of Reason: What Science, Mathematics, and Logic Cannot Tell Us by Noson S. Yanofsky and in some paragraphs of this books, The … homes in gulf shores alabama for saleWebIn effect, the counter-intuitive aspects of the epistemic theory are avoided only at a cost to other intuitions. ... This charge obviously applies more generally to any non-bivalent theory of vagueness. If validated, it would also cast doubt on a disquotationalist account of truth. Many will find this consequence untoward. hiring trends 2022WebThe Epistemic Theory of Vagueness. Stephen Schiffer - 1999 - Philosophical Perspectives 13:481-503. Review: Précis of Vagueness. [REVIEW] Timothy Williamson - 1997 - Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 57 (4):921 - 928. Schiffer on the Epistemic Theory of Vagueness. hiring trends 2022 indiaWebSep 11, 2024 · The epistemic theory of vagueness makes the connection between meaning and use no harder to understand than it already is. At worst, there may be no account to be had, beyond a few vague salutary remarks. Meaning may supervene on … hiring trends 2021 india